In today’s digital economy, businesses frequently purchase software for operations, productivity, and client services. However, what many overlook is that these transactions can attract TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) obligations under the Income Tax Act. Understanding the TDS on software purchase, especially after key judicial rulings, is essential for ensuring compliance and avoiding penalties.
This article explains when and how TDS applies to software transactions, relevant sections, and what the Supreme Court’s landmark judgment means for Indian businesses.
Software purchase transactions are often treated differently under Indian tax law because payments made for the use or transfer of software are considered royalty payments . Since “royalty” is specifically taxable under the Income Tax Act, these transactions fall within the scope of TDS provisions.
The key question businesses must answer is whether the software purchase represents a transfer of copyright or merely the right to use the software. The answer determines whether TDS applies and under which section.
TDS treatment varies based on whether the software is purchased from a domestic supplier or an overseas vendor.
When a business purchases software from an Indian company, such payments may be treated as royalty if the buyer receives the right to use, modify, or reproduce the software. In such cases, TDS under Section 194J applies.
If the transaction is a simple purchase of an off-the-shelf (shrink-wrapped) software product without any transfer of copyright or ownership, it is treated as a goods purchase and TDS is not applicable.
When software is imported from a foreign company, TDS implications are governed by
Section 195
of the Income Tax Act.
If the payment qualifies as “royalty” under Indian law or under the
Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA)
with the vendor’s country, the buyer (Indian company) must deduct TDS before making payment.
The application of TDS on software purchase has been a subject of debate for years, leading to litigation and confusion. The issue was finally clarified by the Supreme Court in a landmark ruling.
In Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence Pvt. Ltd. vs CIT (2021), the Supreme Court ruled that payments made for the purchase of off-the-shelf or shrink-wrapped software do not constitute royalty. Hence, no TDS is required under Section 195 when such software is purchased for personal or internal use.
The Court differentiated between:
Thus, if the buyer only receives the right to use the software and not the underlying copyright, the payment is not considered royalty, and TDS does not apply.
Following this decision, businesses are not required to deduct TDS when purchasing software licenses that do not involve a transfer of copyright. However, companies must carefully review licensing agreements to confirm that the payment is indeed for use and not ownership transfer.
For foreign vendors, always refer to applicable DTAA clauses to determine the correct withholding rate.
The Income Tax Act specifies different TDS sections based on the residency status of the payee and the nature of the payment.
The term royalty, under Section 9(1)(vi), includes consideration for:
Hence, software payments involving such rights are classified as royalty payments.
For payments to Indian vendors, TDS under Section 194J applies at 10% of the payment amount (excluding GST) if the software payment is treated as royalty.
For software purchased from foreign vendors, Section 195 applies.
The payer must obtain a Tax Deduction Account Number (TAN) and deposit TDS with the government before remitting payment abroad.
Understanding TDS applicability on software purchase is crucial for businesses in India. After the Supreme Court’s ruling, the distinction between use of software and transfer of copyright has become clearer.
In short:
Businesses should maintain proper documentation, consult tax advisors when in doubt, and ensure that TDS is correctly deducted and reported wherever applicable.
No. TDS applies only when the software purchase qualifies as a royalty transaction involving the transfer of copyright or rights to reproduce or modify the software.
The Supreme Court clarified that payments for the purchase of standard or off-the-shelf software are not royalty payments and do not attract TDS.
For domestic software purchases from Indian vendors, Section 194J applies. For software purchased from foreign vendors, Section 195 governs TDS on payments to non-residents.
Businesses must calculate TDS based on the applicable DTAA rate, deduct it before making payment, and deposit it with the government through the prescribed challan.
Yes. Businesses can claim TDS credit in their tax return if deducted correctly and reflected in Form 26AS.