Differences Between Regular and Composite Gst Schemes

Overview of the Regular GST Scheme

The Regular GST Scheme is for businesses with a turnover above the prescribed limit. Under this scheme, businesses collect GST from customers and can claim Input Tax Credit (ITC) on their purchases, reducing their tax liability. Regular taxpayers must file monthly or quarterly GST returns, such as  GSTR-1  and  GSTR-3B . This scheme allows the seamless flow of ITC across the supply chain, ensuring transparency and compliance. It is suitable for businesses that deal with taxable goods or services and have significant expenses, as ITC helps lower their overall tax burden. However, it requires detailed record-keeping and regular tax filings.

Get a Free Trial –  Best GST Accounting Software For Small Business

The Composition Scheme is meant for small taxpayers who want simple GST compliance and do not want to file many detailed returns. It is not open to everyone. A business has to match some basic conditions before it can opt in.

In simple words, you can usually choose Composition Scheme if:

• Your annual turnover is within the limit notified for the scheme (as per the latest GST rules).
• You are not making inter state outward supplies of goods or services.
• You are not supplying through e commerce operators that collect tax at source.
• You deal mostly in local sales within your state and your business is small and straightforward.

You cannot opt for Composition Scheme if you are:

• A casual taxable person or non resident taxable person.
• Running a business that supplies non taxable goods or services (like alcohol for human consumption).
• Engaged in manufacture of certain restricted goods (for example, some types of pan masala, tobacco products etc. which are kept outside the scheme).
• Acting as an input service distributor (ISD), e commerce operator or TDS/TCS deductor under GST.

Some service providers and mixed suppliers (goods + services) may also be allowed under a special composition option, but they must still follow the turnover limit and other conditions.

Before recommending Composition to an SME, a CA should always check the latest turnover limit, category of business, type of supplies and state wise rules, and then confirm that all legal criteria are actually met.

Choosing the Right Scheme

Choosing the right GST scheme depends on business size, turnover, and operational needs. The Regular Scheme under GST suits larger businesses with significant expenses and interstate trade, as it allows  ITC claims  and seamless tax flow. The Composition Scheme is better for small businesses, as it prioritizes simplified compliance and lower tax rates. Businesses must evaluate their turnover, the nature of operations, and the trade-off between compliance requirements and tax savings. Consulting a tax professional can help decide the most suitable scheme to ensure compliance and optimize tax efficiency.

Get a Free Trial –  Best Accounting Software For Small Business

There is no single answer that fits every business. Composition Scheme and Regular GST Scheme both have advantages and drawbacks. The “best” choice depends on how your client does business.

When Composition Scheme can be better

Composition may be more suitable when:

• The client is a small trader, small manufacturer or small local restaurant with simple operations.
• Sales are mostly B2C (to end customers) who do not care about input tax credit.
• There is limited purchase of goods or services with GST, so losing ITC is not a big issue.
• The client wants very simple compliance. fewer returns, basic tax payment, less detailed record keeping.

In such cases, paying a small percentage on turnover and avoiding complex monthly returns can save time, effort and professional costs.

When Regular GST Scheme is usually better

Regular scheme is generally a better fit when:

• The business has large or growing turnover and wants to scale operations.
• Sales are mainly B2B, and customers want proper GST invoices and full input tax credit.
• The business needs to do inter state supplies, exports or e commerce.
• There are significant input taxes on raw materials, services, rent, logistics or capital goods.

Under the regular scheme, the taxpayer can collect GST separately, claim full ITC (as per law), and participate properly in the credit chain. This is crucial for competitive pricing in B2B markets.

How a CA should decide

A CA should not look only at the current year’s turnover. They should check:

• Business model. B2B vs B2C, local vs inter state, retail vs wholesale.
• Input tax structure. how much GST is paid on purchases and expenses.
• Future plans. expanding to other states, selling online, adding new product lines.
• Impact on customer expectations and pricing if GST is not shown separately on invoices.

If the business is very small, mainly local and B2C, Composition Scheme can reduce GST headache. If the business is growing, B2B heavy or multi state, Regular GST Scheme is usually the safer and more profitable option in the long run.

Conclusion

Both the regular and composite GST schemes have their respective advantages and disadvantages. While the regular scheme offers flexibility and allows businesses to  claim input tax credits  , it also involves more compliance requirements and higher tax liability. Whereas, the composite scheme offers easy compliance procedures, lower tax rates, and is suitable for small businesses with lower turnovers. However, it has limitations against input tax credits and restricts businesses from supplying goods and services outside the state. Businesses must assess their specific needs and circumstances before choosing between regular and composite GST schemes.